Review: Swipe Right for Monsters by R. O'Leary

Series: Monster Match, Book 1
Author: R. O'Leary
Publication Date: March 5, 2024
Length: 339 pages
Format Read: Paperback
Initial Rating: 10/10 — Final Rating Pending


A Blind Date with a Book That Didn't Disappoint

If you've read my post about Fantasy Forge Book Con, then you already know that I came home with quite a few books, including several from Blind Date with a Book purchases. Swipe Right for Monsters by R. O'Leary was the last book I picked up at the convention, and I deliberately saved it for last when going through my new books because I had already decided it would be the first one I read.

And I am so glad I did!

This book had me giggling, chuckling, and genuinely laughing out loud from beginning to end. It's not often that a book manages to keep me laughing while also making me curious about the mystery unfolding in the background, but this one accomplished both. There were moments when I found myself wondering exactly what was going on and who was targeting our female main character, Nicole, but the story revealed those answers naturally as it progressed. I never felt like I had to spend the entire book trying to piece everything together myself.

The premise alone was enough to catch my attention. Nicole, fresh out of grad school, makes a rather questionable decision involving tequila and a monster dating app called Monstr. What starts as an attempt to find a wealthy monster who might help with her student loans and inherited fixer-upper turns into something much more complicated when five interested monsters enter the picture.

And honestly, what could possibly go wrong with that?

The Physical Book and Its Cover

One thing I don't always get to talk about in my reviews is the physical experience of reading a book. Most of my reading is done on my Kindle, but this time I had an actual paperback in my hands, which gave me the opportunity to appreciate more than just the words on the pages.

First, the cover art is absolutely beautiful. It's one of those covers that catches your attention, but what I appreciate even more is how beautifully it ties into the story itself. After finishing the book, I could appreciate the artwork in a way I couldn't have before reading it.

I also enjoyed getting to sit down with a physical copy again. There's something different about turning the pages, seeing how far you've progressed, and having the book right there in your hands. I'm even considering picking up an ebook copy at some point, simply because I enjoyed the story enough to want it available on my Kindle as well.

Multiple POVs Done Right

Now, I do have to admit that I went into this book with a couple of reservations.

The first was discovering that it was written from multiple points of view. If you've followed my reviews for any length of time, you probably know that multi-POV storytelling can be a hit or miss for me. When it's handled poorly, it can interrupt the flow of a story, repeat scenes unnecessarily, or make the reading experience feel disjointed.

Thankfully, R. O'Leary handled it beautifully.

The POV changes stayed within the main characters, and I didn't find myself reading the same scenes over and over from different perspectives. Instead, each perspective contributed to the story without taking away from what had already happened. The transitions worked well, and the overall flow remained smooth throughout the book.

For someone who can be particularly critical of how authors handle multiple POVs, that was a pleasant surprise.

Six Main Characters, Five Very Different MMCs

My second reservation was the number of main characters.

We aren't talking about one female main character and one male main character here. We have Nicole and five male main characters, which means six central characters whose personalities, interactions, and roles all have to work together.

That is a lot to juggle.

With five MMCs, I was concerned that some of them might end up feeling interchangeable or that their individual personalities would get lost in the crowd. But that wasn't my experience at all. R. O'Leary managed to give each of them his own personality, occupation, and place in Nicole's life.

First, we have Wes, a werewolf shifter and mechanic. He gets plenty of opportunities to put those mechanical skills to use, fixing Nicole's car more than once. He also ends up replacing the tires on all the MMCs' vehicles after someone decides to slash them. It's a good example of how his profession becomes part of the story rather than simply being a detail attached to his character.

Next is Hawthorne, a fae and gardener. He is constantly bringing Nicole fresh flowers, which fits his sweet nature perfectly. He's also the only vegetarian in the group, another little detail that helps distinguish him from the others. There's something particularly fitting about having the gardener be the vegetarian, and it adds to the softer side of his personality.

Then there's Drake, a were-cougar and contractor. If something around Nicole's house needs fixing, he's the man for the job. He's constantly repairing things and building things for her, which makes his profession especially useful considering the condition of the house she inherited.

Last, but certainly not least, are Jasper and Atticus, two vampire lawyers who are both over 200 years old. I'll admit that having two lawyers in the group initially seemed like an unusual choice, but their professions become important as the story progresses. They each bring something different to the group, and their personalities are just as distinct as their occupations.

Jasper is the one with the dirty mind, while Atticus is generally the more thoughtful and measured of the two. Atticus tends to think things through before acting, and he is the more dominant personality in their relationship, with Jasper following his lead.

What I appreciated about all five MMCs was that they didn't feel like five variations of the same character. Their supernatural backgrounds, occupations, and personalities gave each of them something different to contribute. Even with such a large central cast, I never felt overwhelmed trying to keep everyone straight.

In fact, the writing flowed so well that I barely stopped to think about how much work must have gone into making five different MMCs feel like individuals rather than variations of the same character.

That alone impressed me.

Humor, Mystery, and Storytelling

The humor was easily one of my favorite parts of this book. From start to finish, there was something that kept me entertained, whether it was the characters themselves, their interactions, or the situations they found themselves in.

But what made the book work for me was that the humor didn't completely overshadow the story.

There was still a mystery developing, and I was genuinely interested in seeing where it would lead. I had questions about who was targeting Nicole and why, but the answers came through the storytelling rather than feeling forced or unnecessarily drawn out.

I appreciated that balance. I could enjoy the ridiculous, hilarious moments while still being invested in what was happening to the characters.

It's the kind of reading experience that reminds me why I love discovering new authors.

Editing and Grammatical Issues

Now, as much as I enjoyed this book, it wasn't without its problems.

There were some grammatical errors and editing issues that I believe should have been caught before publication. Those things matter to me, and they are something I pay attention to when evaluating a book, regardless of how much I enjoy the story itself.

I haven't completed my usual detailed review process yet, so I'm not going to assign specific deductions or break down individual errors in this initial review. I'll be going back through the book with my review criteria over the next few days to determine exactly where it gains and loses points.

For now, I can say that while the editing issues were noticeable, they didn't prevent me from enjoying the story. The characters, humor, and overall storytelling were strong enough that I still walked away feeling like I'd had a wonderful reading experience.

Giving Newer Books Another Chance

Something else worth mentioning is that Swipe Right for Monsters was published on March 5, 2024.

I know that might not seem particularly important, but for me, it is.

I've become increasingly skeptical of some books published in recent years, particularly when it comes to whether the storytelling and character development live up to the premise. That doesn't mean I automatically dismiss newer releases, but I do tend to approach them with a little more caution.

This book managed to push past those reservations.

It reminded me that there are newer releases out there that can surprise me, entertain me, and give me exactly the kind of reading experience I'm looking for. In fact, it has given some of the newer books sitting on my TBR a renewed chance to catch my attention.

And considering how many books I have waiting to be read, that's saying something!

Final Thoughts

Overall, Swipe Right for Monsters was a fantastic introduction to R. O'Leary's writing and the Monster Match series.

It had a beautiful cover, an entertaining premise, characters with distinct personalities, multiple POVs that actually worked together, and enough humor to keep me laughing throughout all 339 pages. The mystery developed naturally, and I never felt like the story was struggling to balance its six main characters.

Yes, there were editing and grammatical issues, and those will absolutely be taken into consideration when I complete my full evaluation. But even with those flaws, I genuinely enjoyed this book.

I can confidently say that I plan on picking up the remaining books in the Monster Match series, and I'm interested in exploring R. O'Leary's other work as well.

For a book I discovered through a Blind Date with a Book purchase, this turned out to be an excellent surprise.

My Initial Rating: 10/10

Now, before anyone familiar with my rating system starts wondering why I haven't broken out my usual scoring criteria, there's a reason for that!

I wanted to get this review posted on the same day I finished reading the book, which meant I hadn't yet had the opportunity to sit down with my rating materials and go through everything with my usual fine-tooth comb.

Over the next couple of days, I'll be revisiting the book and calculating the actual deductions and bonuses according to my Fiction Master Rating System. Once I've completed that process, I'll update this review with the final score and explain what earned or lost points.

And considering how much I enjoyed this one, I have a feeling its final rating might end up being quite a bit higher than 10/10.

Rating Update: Coming Soon!

Have you read Swipe Right for Monsters or any of R. O'Leary's other books? I'd love to hear what you thought, especially about the humor, the characters, and how the multiple POVs were handled. As always, different opinions are welcome here, and I'm interested in hearing how other readers experienced the story.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: The 5-Time Rejected Gamma & the Lycan King by Stina's Pen

Review: The Dragon God's Mate by Harlow Blaze

Review: Caught in the Barn by Kenzie Haven