Review: Rough Justice by Sarah Castille

 


Published on February 3, 2013, Rough Justice is the first book in the Sinner's Tribe Motorcycle Club series. Having read this book before, I went into this reread expecting to enjoy it just as much as I had the first time around. Unfortunately, revisiting it left me with a very different impression.

This is one of those rare situations where I think my memory of the story was stronger than the experience of actually rereading it.

What surprised me most was how long it took me to finish. As someone who reads extremely quickly and typically tears through books in a day or two, especially books I enjoy, spending six days working through this novel was unusual for me. It wasn't because the book was particularly long or because I lacked time to read. Instead, I found myself repeatedly putting it down and struggling to stay immersed in the story.

For me, that says a lot.

The novel follows Arianne Hunter, a woman raised within motorcycle club culture who has spent much of her life dreaming about something different. When she finally escapes the control of her father, she finds herself caught up with Jagger Knight, president of the rival Sinner's Tribe Motorcycle Club. What follows is a romance filled with attraction, club politics, danger, and the threat of violence between rival groups.

On paper, it has all the ingredients of a strong MC romance.

The problem, at least for me, came from the execution.

The biggest issue throughout the novel was the point-of-view structure. The story shifts between Arianne and Jagger, but often does so without clear transitions or identifying markers. There were multiple occasions where I found myself reading a chapter from Arianne's perspective only for the narration to suddenly switch to Jagger's thoughts before returning again.

Even more confusing, some sections were written in a way that felt as though both perspectives were occupying the same scene simultaneously. Rather than creating a deeper connection to the characters, the constant and often unclear shifts disrupted the flow of the story and made it difficult to remain fully immersed.

This was compounded by repetitive dialogue and recurring statements that appeared throughout the book. Certain thoughts, observations, and reactions seemed to be repeated multiple times, creating the impression that the story was revisiting the same emotional ground rather than moving forward.

The editing also left something to be desired.

Grammar errors and awkward sentence construction appeared often enough that they became noticeable distractions. While no book is completely free of mistakes, these issues occurred frequently enough to pull my attention away from the story itself.

Another area where the novel struggled was worldbuilding.

Readers are given a general sense of where the story takes place and the basic structure of the motorcycle club, but the world never feels particularly developed beyond that. The setting functions as a backdrop for the romance, but it lacks the depth that would have made the club, its territory, and its members feel fully realized.

Ironically, I do not think the plot itself was the problem.

There is a solid story underneath all of these issues. The romance between Arianne and Jagger is interesting enough to hold attention, and the conflict surrounding the clubs provides a reasonable foundation for the narrative. In many ways, this is why the book was frustrating. I could see the potential of what it was trying to accomplish, but the writing choices repeatedly got in the way of my enjoyment.

Had this been my first time reading the book, I might have been more forgiving of some of those flaws. However, rereading it made those issues far more apparent than they were the first time around.

For the first time since I started revisiting many of these books, I found myself unable to justify adding bonus points for emotional impact, memorable character growth, or standout moments. There simply was not enough here to outweigh the technical issues that kept pulling me out of the experience.

That does not mean Rough Justice is a bad book.

It means that for me, the writing style, editing problems, repetitive elements, and confusing POV shifts ultimately overshadowed what could have been a much stronger story.

Favorite Quote

“I'm going to be leaving forever, and forever is a very long time.”

—Arianne, Chapter 22

One thing I would like to start doing in my reviews is highlighting a quote from each book that stood out to me. For Rough Justice, this was the line that stayed with me the most.

The quote comes during a conversation between Arianne and Wheels when she is planning to leave everything behind. She intends to run from her father, leave the club, and walk away from the people she has come to care about. When Wheels questions why she doesn't simply leave immediately, Arianne explains that she wants the opportunity to say goodbye first.

On the surface, it is a simple sentence. However, within the context of the story, it carries a surprising amount of emotional weight.

Arianne is not talking about leaving for a few weeks or even a few months. She believes she is saying goodbye forever. The line captures the reality that "forever" is not just a word—it is a lifetime of missed moments, unfinished conversations, and people she may never see again.

What stood out to me most is how human the moment feels. In a book filled with motorcycle clubs, violence, rivalries, and danger, this quote reminds readers that sometimes the hardest part of leaving is not the act itself but saying goodbye to the people who matter.

Overall, Rough Justice contains the foundation of an enjoyable MC romance, but its execution prevents it from reaching its full potential. Readers who are less bothered by inconsistent POV transitions may enjoy it more than I did, but on reread, the flaws were simply too noticeable for me to ignore.

Final Rating: 5.5/10

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: The 5-Time Rejected Gamma & the Lycan King by Stina's Pen

Review: The Dragon God's Mate by Harlow Blaze

Review: Caught in the Barn by Kenzie Haven