Review: Feral Sins by Suzanne Wright

 


Published on March 3, 2012, Feral Sins is the first book in the Phoenix Pack series. Unlike many of the books I've reviewed recently, this wasn't my first time reading it. In fact, I've read it several times over the years and remembered enjoying it immensely. Going into this reread, however, I wanted to approach it with the same critical eye I've been using for all of my recent reviews.

That meant looking beyond whether I enjoyed the story and examining the writing itself, the pacing, character development, worldbuilding, editing, and overall execution.

After a lot of thought, I settled on a rating that may surprise people who know how much I enjoy this series.

The Negatives

Let's start with the issues I found.

The most noticeable problem throughout the book was the editing. While none of the errors were severe enough to make the story unreadable, there were enough of them to catch my attention during a careful reread.

One example appears early in the novel:

"In truth, he hadn't contacted Roscoe and he had no intention of doing."

The sentence is missing a word and should likely read "doing so." Most readers will automatically correct it in their heads, but it is still an editing mistake that should have been caught.

Another appears when Taryn says:

"Look, psycho boy, I don't know what you're problem is..."

In this instance, "you're" should be "your."

These are relatively minor issues, but they occur often enough throughout the novel that they become noticeable.

There are also some elements of the story that feel very much like a product of the early 2010s paranormal romance boom. Certain relationship dynamics, possessive behaviors, and pack politics may not appeal to every reader, particularly those looking for a more modern interpretation of shifter romance.

The Positives

Where Feral Sins truly shines is in its characters.

Taryn Warner remains one of the most entertaining protagonists I've encountered in paranormal romance. She is sarcastic, stubborn, fiercely independent, and completely unwilling to be intimidated by anyone—including an Alpha male who is accustomed to getting his own way.

One of the things I appreciated most during this reread was that her strength never feels forced. She doesn't spend the book telling readers she's strong. Instead, she demonstrates it repeatedly through her actions, decisions, and refusal to back down when pressured.

A perfect example comes when Trey attempts to exert his authority over her:

"We should probably clear this up right now, psycho boy. I don't have a submissive bone in my body so don't bark at me unless you're happy to be ignored."

That single line tells readers almost everything they need to know about Taryn.

Likewise, another early quote highlights both her humor and her determination:

"Note this: If you try to hand me over to Roscoe when he comes, I'll claw your balls off."

It's funny, but it's also completely serious. Taryn is not a passive participant in her own story, and she makes that clear from the very beginning.

Trey also proved more interesting on this reread than I remembered.

Early in the novel, he views mating purely as a strategic arrangement. He wants an alliance, not a relationship. One passage in particular stood out:

"Yes, but I don't want cosmic, soul-moving, imprinting shit in my life." In fact, he was pretty sure he wouldn't be capable of feeling the kind of emotions that kept a mating alive.

This moment serves as an important benchmark for his character. It establishes exactly where Trey stands emotionally at the beginning of the story, which makes it easier to appreciate the changes he undergoes as the relationship develops.

Humor

If there is one thing Suzanne Wright consistently does well, it is humor.

Much of that humor comes directly from Taryn's sharp tongue and refusal to filter her thoughts.

One quote that made me laugh during this reread was:

"You know, jamming your fingers into your ears might just prevent all that hot air from gushing out of your mouth."

Moments like these help balance the heavier themes and conflicts throughout the novel while making Taryn an incredibly entertaining character to follow.

Favorite Quote

While there were many quotes throughout Feral Sins that made me laugh, this one was easily my favorite:

"Just give me a second. Attempting to give a fuck... Attempting harder to give a fuck... Sorry, there was an error. Fuck not given."

—Taryn, Chapter 5

Taryn's sharp tongue and sarcastic sense of humor are some of the strongest aspects of her character, and this quote captures both perfectly.

What makes the quote work so well is that it feels completely natural coming from Taryn. It isn't humor for the sake of humor—it is a reflection of who she is as a character. Throughout the novel, she consistently refuses to be intimidated, controlled, or pressured into becoming someone she isn't, and that attitude shines through in moments like this.

If I could instantly recall one quote from this book to use in real life, it would probably be this one. The fact that most people wouldn't know where it came from unless they've read the book only makes it even better.

Final Thoughts

This reread forced me to think carefully about how I wanted to rate Feral Sins.

There were plenty of things I loved. The characters remain memorable, the humor still works, and the relationship between Trey and Taryn is engaging from start to finish. At the same time, there are enough editing issues and dated elements that I couldn't ignore them simply because I enjoyed the story.

Ultimately, I decided it would only be fair to evaluate this book using the same standards I've applied to every other review on this blog.

Even after the deductions, Feral Sins remains a genuinely enjoyable read and an entertaining introduction to the Phoenix Pack series. The strengths outweigh the weaknesses, but the weaknesses are still there.

For me, that lands this book solidly in the middle of the pack: a good read that I would happily recommend to fans of paranormal romance, even if it isn't quite as flawless as I remembered.

Final Rating: 7/10

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: The 5-Time Rejected Gamma & the Lycan King by Stina's Pen

Review: The Dragon God's Mate by Harlow Blaze

Review: Caught in the Barn by Kenzie Haven