DNF Review: Dark Protector by Avelyn Paige & Geri Glenn
Published on May 28, 2020, Dark Protector is the first book in the Black Hoods MC series.
This marks the first official DNF (Did Not Finish) review on my blog.
I made it to Chapter 23, approximately 61% of the way through the book, before deciding to put it down.
That wasn't a decision I made lightly.
I generally try to give books every opportunity to pull me in, especially when they belong to genres I regularly enjoy. Unfortunately, after reaching more than halfway through the novel, I realized I was still waiting for the story to genuinely engage me.
At a certain point, I had to ask myself a simple question:
Was I continuing because I cared about the story, or because I hoped it would eventually become a story I wanted to read?
The answer was the latter.
For now, Dark Protector is joining my DNF shelf.
Why I Chose to DNF
The problem wasn't that nothing was happening.
In fact, quite a bit was happening.
The problem was that none of it felt as though it was building toward anything meaningful.
The story seemed to circle multiple plotlines without ever fully committing to one. Just as one thread appeared ready to develop, the focus would shift elsewhere. As a result, I never felt grounded in the story or invested in where it was going.
More importantly, I never found myself becoming attached to the characters.
By Chapter 23, I was still waiting for meaningful character development, meaningful worldbuilding, or some larger narrative thread that would make me eager to keep turning pages.
That moment never came.
The MC Element
One of my biggest disappointments was the lack of actual motorcycle club presence throughout the story.
This book is marketed as an MC romance, yet throughout the 61% I completed, I was given very little insight into the club itself.
I was told that GreenPeace belonged to a motorcycle club.
I was told that he occasionally had club business to handle.
But beyond that, the MC world remained largely unexplored.
Readers are never given a meaningful look into the club's culture, structure, brotherhood, or daily life. Other club members receive little attention, and the motorcycle club never feels like an active part of the story.
Instead, it feels more like a label attached to GreenPeace than a living, breathing part of the narrative.
For me, this was particularly disappointing because one of the things I enjoy most about well-written MC romances is the sense of community. The club becomes a character in its own right, influencing the plot, shaping relationships, and creating a world that feels distinct from everyday life.
That never happened here.
By the time I reached Chapter 23, I still felt like I knew very little about the Black Hoods MC beyond the fact that GreenPeace belonged to it.
Tropes vs. Story
Another issue I struggled with was the way familiar tropes were used throughout the story.
There is nothing wrong with tropes. Some of my favorite books rely heavily on them.
The difference is that in the strongest stories, tropes support the narrative.
Here, it often felt as though the narrative existed to support the tropes.
Rather than helping build the characters, expand the world, or advance the story, many of the familiar elements felt included simply because they were expected.
As I continued reading, I found myself increasingly aware of the tropes rather than becoming immersed in the story itself.
That made it difficult to stay invested.
Final Thoughts
Not every book is going to work for every reader, and that's okay.
I don't think Dark Protector is completely without merit. There were moments that showed potential, and clearly the authors were aiming for suspense, romance, and danger.
Unfortunately, the story never came together in a way that worked for me.
By the time I reached 61% completion, I realized I was no longer reading to find out what happened next.
I was reading in the hope that something would finally make me care about what happened next.
For me, that's usually a sign that it's time to move on.
Could my opinion change in the future?
Absolutely.
That's why this book is being placed on my DNF shelf rather than being permanently written off.
Maybe a few years from now I'll revisit it and discover something I missed.
For now, however, this is where my journey with Dark Protector ends.
DNF Status: Chapter 23 (61% Complete)
Shelf Placement: DNF Shelf (May Revisit)

Comments
Post a Comment